I decided to finish up a fisherman to 120 and figured that since I was at it I may as well get a couple of other fishers working too. The fisherman I was working had 115 fishing, the other two just 100. The one I was working also had 1800+ luck in his suit, the other two had none... this is the result(see pic).
So my question - is it skill or is it luck that gets better results ??