I am sorry, the "rough" comment I made was in response to an earlier suggestion you do it without sedation. I guess I was suggesting that maybe that was not a good idea.
I honestly think you should just do it. I had my wisdom teeth out while sedated, and I was even awake for part of it, but it was still no big deal. I opened my eyes to see the dentist had a knee on the side of my head to give him leverage while yanking on a tooth and I was flying so high I didn't care. I was eating the next day too -- if only meatloaf -- and I never had a problem. You have definitely put up with much worse now, maybe even while on motrin.