I'm new to pvp, but I see two, possibly three, immediate issues. First, It's almost never necessary to take Chivalry that high. You can Holy Light 100% with 105 Chiv, and you really probably don't need it even that high. Second, I think, but am not sure, that they've eliminated the lumberjacking bonus from pvp. And, third, If you're going to use resist instead of a trapped box you need a minimum of 120 resist. There are some excellent templates on this site, and as I'm learning pvp it has surprised me how few skills actually need to be maxed out.